As I mentioned when I discovered Wordie and Coastr, I’ve yet to find a book-oriented social network that’s inspired me to register. And it’s not like there’s any shortage of them. Here’s an alphabetical list of all the players I know of, annotated with deconstructive criticism. The bold-face names are serious contenders.
- aNobii: Multilingual Hong Kong-based book-lister with a clean design.
- Bibliophil.org: Personable. Feature-rich. Unfortunate design.
- Booktribes: Bookish social network with extremely busy pages.
- BooksWellRead: Way too many ellipses…
- Buchpfade.de: Bookish community site for German speakers.
- ChainReading: Aimed at reading addicts, but site activity doesn’t suggest an addicted user base.
- ConnectViaBooks: Socializing, rather than cataloging, is the main focus of this London-based booklover site. Some real potential here.
- Douban: Bookish community site aimed at some of the world’s 1.1 billion Chinese speakers.
- Goodreads: Simple bookish social network that emphasizes book recommendations from other users.
- GuruLib: For readers with a compulsive desire to catalog everything they own. Not pretty.
- Lib.rario.us: Media collection organizer in a precarious position.
- LibraryThing: The most established bookish community site of the bunch, with active developers. They just hired Wordie’s John McGrath and they’re encouraging people to make Chuck Close-style mosaics of themselves out of book covers. One to watch.
- Listal: Taggerific media-cataloging site with rich profiles, a surplus of content and widgets galore.
- Mediachest.com: Established media-cataloging site whose best feature may be groups.
- Reader2: As in “reader squared.” I found it difficult to browse.
- Reliwa.de: German book and music social network. Seems pretty active.
- Squirl.info: John McGrath, who created Wordie, is the co-founder of this social collection organizer, so I want to like it, but I don’t.
- Shelfari: Nicely designed bookish social network out to take out LibraryThing. They’ve got big widgets.
- ShelfCentered.com: Lists are called shelves here but you can’t begin browsing them until you register.
I guess what I really want is a combination of Wordie, Flickr and Amazon, with the book information pages of Google Book Search (maps included!) and highly customizable widgets. Is that too much to ask?
21 Comments
Have you come across anything that is basically a cataloging site (like LibraryThing) but allows other users (that you accept – friends, really) to see your lists and to add or manipulate them somehow.
For example, I have used book want lists that, if someone sees and buys for me, then they would mark the book on the site as purchased.
ShelfCentered might be what you’re looking for, Jason. I haven’t registered but they have a wishlist feature that allows your friends to mark the items they’ve purchased for you.
Shelfari is definitely tempting for it’s good looks, but I just can’t see myself entering all my books instead of, you know, reading them. Listing collector’s items (and old or first-edition books that really serve the purpose of collector items) a-la squirl, sure, maybe if I was bored—the primary purpose of a collection is to show it off. But listing all the books I’ve ever read seems insufferably tedious—the primary purpose of books is reading them!
On the other hand I did make friends with a stranger on the other coast in the early days of Friendster based on our mutual listing of the same obscure book. Haven’t emailed her in years, but we did have a few enjoyable games of email Scrabble. So maybe there’s something to it after all.
“Its good looks”! Damnit. I think I had once posted a very long diatribe against Nabisco for precisely that mistake.
Are there a lot of folks visiting these book social networks? Which of these are the most popular so we can add on http://www.socialurl.com?
I personally used Collectors Quest new platform to organize my books:
http://www.collectorsquest.com/collection/36/my-bookshelf.html
I use gurulib for a while, and I don’t care about its “not so pretty” design. You should try to test it longer, it is really user friendly, and the smarter for great collections of book, movies or documents, furthermore if you often grow it.
I personally don’t care about the social features, I tried a bunch beffore choose gurulib, and it’s the most complete for organization.
I used reader2 for a while but I found goodreads much nicer
2 french : Babelio and Zazieweb.
Hubert Guillaud forgot to mention the pionneer in France : L’agora des Livres : http://www.agoradeslivres.com
a small audience (perhaps) but a real network of passionate readers (for french speaking persons only)
Have you tried Bookcrossing? I used to be a very active member, read tons of books traded through the site and went to tons of meetups. It is a great site with an excellent and very active community.
Here are a bunch more places to list your books – some of which are mentioned. Sites to List Your Books. I use several off and on but it is hard to keep track of them all.
I got the same feel as well, till I tried http://www.bookjetty.com. It’s the newest one launched, quite promising.
thanks for the list. this really helped
A new one you might want to check out for good book recommendations is http://www.Juicespot.ca. Nice, clean design. Users share comment on books.
thanks for the wonderful list.
Nice List, Thanks
Weread(http://weread.com) is a community for book lovers. You can rate, review and discuss about a book and share them with your loved ones.
One site you have not mentioned is Authonomy (http://www.authonomy.com)run by the publishing house Harper Collins. On it unpublished, self-published and other obscure authors can display extracts of their work. The books are arranged in a charts system according to how many fellow memebers have backed them.
Sorry, The Authonomy address should be http://www.authonomy.com
Please add to list. Topics – Social Networking, Photo and video sharing.
http://www.eyaad.com
Thanks
11 Trackbacks
[...] (via: fimoculous) (tags: social+media social+networks books community socialmedia socialnetworks) permalink | categories: All other | Time posted: 12:17 am on Tuesday, February 6th,2007 [...]
[...] The Big List of Bookish Social Networks [...]
[...] Check out the Visual Bookshelf app on Facebook, which offers an effective way of sharing your books with your social network. Also be sure to scan Deeplinking’s compilation, The Big List of Bookish Social Networks. [...]
[...] The Big List of Bookish Social Networks at Deeplinking – [...]
[...] The Big List of Bookish Social Networks [Deeplinking] – Handy. [...]
[...] We came across this interesting post earlier this week – it’s a look at the various bookish social-networking sites that are out there, along with recommendations of the best. [...]
[...] Community from a publisher perspective can all too easily mean community around the products a publisher produces rather than the space as a whole including those parts of it occupied by other publishers . Google, Amazon, librarything, whoever, do not have this limitation, whilst already existing as destinations for those looking to find out more about books or use them as a vector of contact. On top of this they are eager for any content they can get to add value to their own brand. [...]
[...] A year ago I rounded up a fairly big list of bookish social networks. I’ve since tried a number of them (as the list has grown to something like 40 bookish competitors) and was pretty hyped up about Google Book Search until their embeddable book clippings started breaking and I realized their full-text search only covers a small percentage of the books I’m interested in searching. [...]
[...] NPR’s Martha Woodroof interviewed me for a piece on bookish social networks last month and the spot aired on All Things Considered today. Check it out here. Since the interview I’ve been all over LibraryThing. And since LibraryThing started bridging the gap between virtual and real bookish social networks with LibraryThing Local, GoodReads has hooked up with BookTour (which used to date LibraryThing). And some people are still just reading books. [...]
[...] Big list of Bookish social Networks???. Trackback Address. 1 Jason Feb 5th, 2007 at 5:19 pm …http://deeplinking.net/bookish-social-networks/Categorized List of Social Media and Social Networking Websites TraffikdA definitive list of over [...]
[...] swearing (with horrible punctuation, no less) that I was far too cool and/or busy actually reading my books [...]